Question: Are the custodian’s decisions to release the personnel records with redactions to sensitive personal information and to withhold the employee-evaluation records consistent with the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)?
Brief Response: Because I have not seen any of the responsive records the custodian intends to release, I cannot opine about the releasability of any specific document or the need to redact any specific piece of information from an otherwise releasable document. However, based on the information provided, the custodian’s decisions to release the personnel records with redactions to sensitive personal information and to withhold the employee-evaluation records are likely consistent with the FOIA.
Question: Is the custodian’s decision to release the records as redacted consistent with the FOIA?
Brief Response: In my opinion, the custodian’s decision is partially consistent with the FOIA. The custodian may properly release the identifiable personnel records, including the administrative employment-status record on page 2 and the suspension notice on page 32, subject to any necessary redactions. Pages 3 and 31 are employee-evaluation or job-performance records. Page 31 should be withheld, and page 3 should be withheld unless the custodian determines that the employee’s resignation constituted a constructive termination and that the remaining elements of the four-part test for disclosure have been satisfied. Because the records identified in Section 7 are so extensively redacted, I cannot determine whether they have been properly classified or whether the redactions are consistent with the FOIA. Under A.C.A. § 25-19-105(a)(3)(B), if responsive records are subject to exemptions, the custodian must identify the applicable exemptions.
Question: Is the custodian’s decision to release the requested records with redactions consistent with the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)?
Brief Response: In my opinion, the custodian’s decisions are mostly consistent with the FOIA. The custodian has correctly classified the first four records as the employee’s personnel records and has properly redacted certain exempt information from them. However, the second personnel record appears to contain the employee’s personal email address. If so, that information should be redacted before the record is released. The custodian has also correctly classified a suspension letter as an employee-evaluation record and has redacted what appears to be the employee’s home address and employee identification number. If that is the information that was redacted, that decision is likewise consistent with the FOIA.