Question: Is the custodianโs decision to release the records as redacted consistent with the FOIA?
Brief Response: In my opinion, the custodianโs decision is partially consistent with the FOIA. The custodian may properly release the identifiable personnel records, including the administrative employment-status record on page 2 and the suspension notice on page 32, subject to any necessary redactions. Pages 3 and 31 are employee-evaluation or job-performance records. Page 31 should be withheld, and page 3 should be withheld unless the custodian determines that the employeeโs resignation constituted a constructive termination and that the remaining elements of the four-part test for disclosure have been satisfied. Because the records identified in Section 7 are so extensively redacted, I cannot determine whether they have been properly classified or whether the redactions are consistent with the FOIA. Under A.C.A. ยง 25-19-105(a)(3)(B), if responsive records are subject to exemptions, the custodian must identify the applicable exemptions.
Question: Is the custodianโs decision to release the requested records with redactions consistent with the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)?
Brief Response: In my opinion, the custodianโs decisions are mostly consistent with the FOIA. The custodian has correctly classified the first four records as the employeeโs personnel records and has properly redacted certain exempt information from them. However, the second personnel record appears to contain the employeeโs personal email address. If so, that information should be redacted before the record is released. The custodian has also correctly classified a suspension letter as an employee-evaluation record and has redacted what appears to be the employeeโs home address and employee identification number. If that is the information that was redacted, that decision is likewise consistent with the FOIA.
Question 1: Is the county required to pay for clothing for indigent defendants to wear to court appearances pursuant to these statutes or any other law? Regardless of whether it is required to pay, may the county lawfully pay for this expense if it so chooses?
Brief Response: The county is not required to pay for clothing for indigent defendants to wear at court appearances. But Amendment 55 and A.C.A. ยงยง 14-14-802(a)(1), 14-14-802(b), and 14-20-102(a) likely allow a county to purchase clothing for indigent defendants to wear at court appearances before juries.
Question 2: Is the Public Defender Commission required to pay for such clothing pursuant to these statutes or any other law? Regardless of whether it is required to pay, may the Public Defender Commission lawfully pay for this expense if it so chooses?
Brief Response: No, the Public Defender Commission is not required to pay for clothing for indigent defendants to wear at jury trials or other court appearances. And no state law expressly authorizes the Commission to purchase clothing for indigent defendants.
Question 3: May the indigent defendants keep any clothing purchased by the county, or must it be returned to the county after use?
Brief Response: In general, if the county purchases clothing for indigent defendants, that clothing would constitute county personal property. And the county ordinarily may not donate such property to private individuals. However, a reviewing court would likely find that the quorum court may, under A.C.A. ยงย 14-20-102(a)(4), enact an ordinance to either (1)ย designate the clothing as a consumable expenditure that need not be returned to the county or (2) authorize the county judge to transfer title to the clothing to the defendant as an indigent-defense expenditure.
Question 4: May the indigent defendants keep any clothing purchased by the Public Defender Commission, or must it be returned to the county after use?
Brief Response: Please see my response to Question 2.
Question 5: May the Quorum Court lawfully appropriate county funds for this purpose?
Brief Response: Probably yes; a reviewing court would likely find that a quorum court may appropriate county funds for this purpose because (1) no state law prohibits the expenditure and (2) the expenditure is sufficiently related to county affairs under Amendment 55 and A.C.A. ยงยง 14-14-802 and 14-20-102(a).
Question 6: Assuming that a county may lawfully pay this expense and funds may lawfully be appropriated, may a Circuit or District Court lawfully order the county to pay for this expense, or must such an expense be approved by the County Judge through the regular approval and disbursement process for county claims set forth in Amendment 55, Section 3?
Brief Response: As discussed above, the county is not required to pay for clothing for indigent defendants to wear at court appearances. Thus, a circuit or district court cannot lawfully order the county to pay for this expense, and the expense must be approved through the countyโs regular approval and disbursement process for county claims.
Question 7: May the County Treasurer lawfully pay such an expense without an approved claim from the County Judge?
Brief Response: Please see my response to Question 1. A reviewing court would likely find that Amendment 55 allows a county to pay this expense through its regular approval and disbursement process for county claims.